Industry Experts

Q. Which bath tub is more durable?

Q. What is better enamel steel tubs or acrylic?

Powered by

Q. Bathtub: cheap, durable, quiet?

we need to replace our 60x30 bathtub in a small bathroom. this tub will be used daily as a shower. (yes, we considered shower-only but that's what's in the master bath. we'd like to keep a tub just in case we need one for a future grandchild or foot soak.) i want a tub that is durable, inexpensive, quiet and easy for my plumber to install. **cast iron sounds good, but the weight will likely mean the install price soars, especially since this tub will be installed in a very small bathroom off a very small hall. not a lot of maneuver room getting inside. however the toilet is currently out of the bathroom so once in, the install should be a bit easier. **porcelain over steel is cheap and durable, but i've read many complaints about super loud noise as the tub fills. this will likely mean it will be loud during my son's long, early morning showers and, frankly, i want to wake each morning thinking we are having an earthquake. also, i've heard it chips easier than enameled cast iron. **acrylic seems like it might be a good alternative but i'm confused between brands, how to tell acrylic from acrylic-covered fiberglass, what's good, what's bad, etc. there doesn't seem to be a lot of acrylic-specific information other than waxing it to keep it looking good. **acrylic-covered fiberglass is said to be flimsy and not good quality. any buzz words i should look for to make sure i don't mistake one of these for an acrylic tub? **americast--not sure about the material. it's made by american standard. some say its wonderful, the best alternative to cast iron and acrylic. (which makes me want one) others hate it, say they'll never buy it again. (which makes me rethink wanting one) the three walls surrounding the tub will be tiled. do i need a special tub for this? (i've seen some with a lip and some without a lip. not sure what is required.) fyi: we are looking for a basic, no-frills tub, no whirlpool jets, no fancy design or shape. just a good, durable, quiet, inexpensive ($350 or less), easy-to-install tub for shower use. thoughts? suggestions? opinions on what to avoid?